I am trying to fork a project but no namespaces are listed. input: Specifies static inputs or variables such as a parameter, task result, and execution status. I have a self-managed GitLab CE v13.1.3 on CentOS7 (omnibus installation). Procedure Prepare the ArgoCD pipeline configuration: Create a Git repository with the directory structure similar to the example directory. Add LDAP group to "external_groups" list in Helm chart values file. On the other hand and strictly speaking, this limits product features in a sense that accessing any data has to always be scoped to a (root) namespace. On the other hand, there are features which would require a cross-shard scan: These features have conflicting access patterns with the idea of sharding by namespace. All migrations up? 45/29 yes I am new on Gitlab. 2/27 yes Workflow groups are functional areas where work is performed. This is mostly a product question to start with, because it is rather unlikely this works out without needing product changes. Extracting the reference deployment creates the out/argocd/deployment directory referenced in the following procedure. Both contain many sub-groups, projects, a lot of issues, merge requests, CI data and so on. 24/32 yes 3/20 yes As a sidenote: If I try to create a new project via the "+" button on the top nav bar it does not show the company as available namespace either. Using RVM: no https://gitlab.com/pages/hugo#gitlab-user-or-group-pages Share Follow answered Mar 24, 2019 at 14:21 Jan 8,982 5 48 77 Add a comment Your Answer 2/56 yes Database config exists? 89/65 yes skipped (omnibus-gitlab has no init script) Using LDAP: yes Upgrade GitLab by deploying GitLab version 12.10.1 to GKE using Helm chart 3.3.1. If you're running an Open Source project, please also consider the GitLab for Open Source program which can provide more CI/CD minutes as well as additional storage. 289/137 yes Why is Julia in cyrillic regularly transcribed as Yulia in English? 2/24 yes 26/148 yes 25/8 yes Here is the Namespace To Workflow Relationship Diagram for a visual understanding of the Namespace structure: User Namespace Can be an Ultimate Namespace Also referred to as Personal Namespace Only Projects can be created under Users Users are not limited to the number of Projects User namespaces are found in data by Namespace_Type = 'User' 24/25 yes 95% of users interact with about 4 top-level namespaces or less (including their user namespace). I found I already had one such project but could not create a second (and got this same namespace error). 29/55 yes In this article. Hi. analysis is needed to show the overall usage of Project Namespaces by users. 24/143 yes Database contains orphaned GroupMembers? Git user has default SSH configuration? This can be done by navigating to your 28/42 yes 45/84 yes What I am wondering now (just noticed that) is that the last part of the Project URL is krause, whereas other (older) (private) projects are shown like Krause, Markus / project001 . 89/112 yes 323/159 yes 3/61 yes Let's look at a few examples: The gist of this idea is to slice all data horizontally by the respective top-level namespace. Each destination namespace needs to have that network policy applied to it. I am a member of a group . NOTE: Only a Geo primary node accepts this request. 24/72 yes Active users: 298 24/103 yes 89/62 yes Only from Admin Area, New Project button is available, but selecting any group (also a new group) as namespace, the New Project Creation fails with the error The form contains the following error: Namespace is not valid. Features are determined by a subscription assigned to a namespace and subsequent namespaces will have the same features. Product: Many product features have been identified to potentially become very slow/expensive or break with this approach. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, Project Creation/Transfer failed: Namespace is not valid. 325/163 yes Subscriptions are assigned to a namespace for Gitlab.com SaaS Instances and Licenses are assigned at the Instance level of Self-Managed Implementations. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. I (and other users) used to create some personal projects unter my user name as namespace (just the login name derived from LDAP) where I do have several git repositories, so this actually worked (also for other users) . 89/77 yes Git version >= 2.31.0 ? Success Selecting any groups the "New Project" button is disappeared; only "New subgroup" button is visible Only from Admin Area, "New Project" button is available, but selecting any group (also a new group) as namespace, the New Project Creation fails with the error " The form contains the following error: Namespace is not valid " subscription). 14/68 yes 289/138 yes GitLab Shell: GitLab Shell version >= 13.19.1 ? System information On GitLab.com, this makes up about 75% of the audit log data, which cannot be sharded by namespace. Is authorized keys file accessible? A summary for this analysis can be found in "A Note on the Technical Complexities with Sharding by Namespace" (GitLab-internal link). 45/83 yes 24/71 yes yes Depending on how isolated the audit log feature is from the rest of the application, we may want to think about feasibility of a different sharding dimension here (time or user). So to create a Subgroup you use the Group API and specify the Parent_id which is the integer id of the group. yes Git Version: 2.27.0 24/3 yes You must enter a valid input. yes OK, in my case the problem was on the user configuration. 14/71 yes 45/147 yes Ultimate namespaces are classified as Paid, Free or Trial depending on whether a subscription is attached and the type of subscription it is. Always let the user select a desired namespace for the search. We can see this by analyzing the database schema statically. 209/100 yes 209/102 yes yes the ability to write the same data in different locations), this hinders our ability to scale the read-write capacity - because these writes can only happen on a single cluster. 114/69 yes 323/160 yes @dsumenkovic the question was " Create a new project in a group using API ". Let's decompose this example: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/database-team/team-tasks 45/86 yes UPDATE Even exporting the project from GitLab 12.6.1 ee and importing it to gitlab.com leads to the namespace error Edited by Stephan K. 2 years ago URL: https://gitlab.int.master.lan For example, we could have an admin to always select a namespace of interest and we would only show data for a single namespace at a time. However, this is not a static analysis anymore but rather involves maintaining lookup information to track which shards are relevant for a given user. 2/41 yes Testing at GitLab is a first class citizen, not an afterthought. I deleted the one project and THEN I was able to successfully create a new project. yes Implies there is some kind of project limit BUT the error certainly doesnt hint at that. GitLab information 6/9 yes At this moment, No one includes also Administrators, but the meaning/behavior of this configuration doesnt make sense and it is unuseful. Project Namespaces by Membership Directory: /opt/gitlab/embedded/service/gitlab-rails 89/49 yes gitlab-shell self-check successful, Sidekiq: Running? This would help to avoid scans across all shards and limit it closer to what is relevant. GitLab config up to date? skipped (omnibus-gitlab has no init script) Init script up-to-date? Rake Version: 12.3.3 45/134 yes This can be thought of as a database tool we have at our disposal to considerably improve performance and scalability of the application. Uploads directory tmp has correct permissions? Based on that, we conducted an analysis of how many projects, groups and top-level namespaces users interact with on GitLab.com. Init script exists? For example, it may even be undesirable for a SaaS customer on GitLab.com to accidentally @-mention users outside their organization. In the ideal scenario for namespace sharding, these features would be constrained by a namespace. Success No one ever hit that? Log in to GitLab, navigate to personal profile page and try to create a personal project. Can the UVLO threshold be below the minimum supply voltage? 89/60 yes Gitlab receives Service Ping information at the Instance or Namespace Ping level. 45/140 yes 25/104 yes gitlabproject name namespace is not valid 1 Gitlab GitlabURL Calculating expected value from quantiles. yes (7.11.1). I need a writable /usr directory to run Gentoo Prefix. Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! yes The benefit from this locality is the ability to optimize for different cases across the application - we don't have to find the single common sharding dimension for everything. Database contains orphaned GroupMembers? System: "https://gitlab.example.com/api/v4/namespaces", "https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/e64c7d89f26bd1972efa854d13d7dd61?s=80&d=identicon", "https://gitlab.example.com/groups/group1", "https://gitlab.example.com/groups/foo/bar", "https://gitlab.example.com/api/v4/namespaces/2", "https://gitlab.example.com/api/v4/namespaces/group1", "https://gitlab.example.com/api/v4/namespaces/my-group/exists?parent_id=1", Features available to Starter and Bronze subscribers, Change from Community Edition to Enterprise Edition, Zero-downtime upgrades for multi-node instances, Upgrades with downtime for multi-node instances, Change from Enterprise Edition to Community Edition, Configure the bundled Redis for replication, Generated passwords and integrated authentication, Example group SAML and SCIM configurations, Create a Pages deployment for your static site, Rate limits for project and group imports and exports, Tutorial: Use GitLab to run an Agile iteration, Configure OpenID Connect with Google Cloud, Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST), Frontend testing standards and style guidelines, Beginner's guide to writing end-to-end tests, Best practices when writing end-to-end tests, Shell scripting standards and style guidelines, Add a foreign key constraint to an existing column, Case study - namespaces storage statistics, GitLab Flavored Markdown (GLFM) developer documentation, GitLab Flavored Markdown (GLFM) specification guide, Version format for the packages and Docker images, Add new Windows version support for Docker executor, Architecture of Cloud native GitLab Helm charts, Returns a list of namespaces the user is authorized to view based on the search criteria, In GitLab 14.2 and later, returns a list of owned namespaces only. 321/158 yes Any ideas ? The same type of namespace like: Omniauth Providers: GitLab Shell Get existence of a namespace by path. Where example.io is the domain GitLab Pages is served from, 192.0.2.1 is the IPv4 address of your GitLab instance, and 2001:db8::1 is the IPv6 address. 24/76 yes 26/20 yes DELETE /geo_nodes/:id Repair a Geo node To repair the OAuth authentication of a Geo node. 1 Answer Sorted by: 0 I found a way: Just rename your project to namespace.gitlab.io, where namespace is your username or groupname. Creating a project in a group does work as always, transferring this to my user namespace does also lead to an error message Transfer failed, please contact an admin.. 90/99 yes When a User, Group or Project is created, an associated namespace record is also created. 268/141 yes I already found that forum topic (I mentioned that in the last part of my first post), the Default project creation protection is set to Developers + Maintainers. Thanks for your contributions! I dont use LDAP, so mine is commented, but it will give you an idea to compare against: Thanks for the hint. GitLab is built on PostgreSQL which does not support native sharding (however, it's on the community roadmap). As @fuzes confirmed cluster re-creation can be a workaround for this issue. This should successfully associate the subscription. no We explored what is needed for database sharding and we also got an idea of how well this would work with GitLab. To further diagnose this, check the output of the ingress responsible for the domain, and follow it down the "chain" until you identify where the 404 is being responded by. 24/26 yes At the moment, when trying to create a personal project as an external user, you're met with "Namespace not valid" error. Before we dive into details, let's summarize shortly what is ideal for this sharding approach: The following section details apply these points to GitLab. Depending on implementation details, it may be difficult to implement parallel cross shard scans. Usernames and group names fall under a special category called This means, search cannot go across multiple namespaces. Uploads directory exists? GitLab config exists? yes (2.7.2) Specifically, gitlab generates refs/merge-requests/*, refs/pipelines/* and refs/keep-around/* and they all contain massive amount of data that are useless for the bitbake build purposes. 268/128 yes 327/165 yes Only User and Group namespaces can be Ultimate Namespaces. I am running a self-hosted CE version for GitLab version 13.11.2 on CentOS 7. Do I have to activate the subdomains somehow? How does this relate to partitioning efforts? 14/62 yes Issues: This is a representative example for data that originates from within a namespace, but also has conflicting access patterns. Go Version: unknown. Redis available via internal API: OK Both values are updated In that sense, partitioning is a tool that is readily available for us to make use of now and one that does not introduce operational complexity. search the docs. The root of this hierarchy is called "top-level namespace". Tmp directory writable? Listing and working with a project issue tracker including search etc (. 24/39 yes Steps to reproduce I am not sure if this is the correct sequence, but this is my current setup. Uploads directory exists? NAMESPACE 89/52 yes 45/135 yes 45/113 yes I use LDAP as authentication source, krause would match the uid, but Krause, Markus is cn. If you didn't find what you were looking for, You can have as many Ultimate Namespaces as needed, but a subscription can only be assigned to a single Ultimate Namespace. 89/59 yes yes Gem Version: 2.7.10 Here is the Namespace To Workflow Relationship Diagram for a visual understanding of the Namespace structure: Namespace Service Pings information is sent to Gitlab showing the usage of the product by namespace. Repository storage paths: GitLab Shell: GitLab Shell version >= 13.3.0 ? Init script up-to-date? post on the GitLab forum. Learn more about .NET C# Programming Browse Top C# Programmers From Gi krause June 1, 2021, 1:46pm #4 Hi iwalker, Let's use /gitlab-org and /gitlab-com as two example top-level namespaces. 24/73 yes I had to disable external user to make it work. Ruby version >= 2.5.3 ? 14/64 yes gitlabNamespace is not validgitlabNamespace is not valid,gitlabNamespace is not valid,group 3/66 yes Namespace, hoge66: 2/17 yes 247/123 yes Let's start off by defining common nomenclature. 24/38 yes yes Identified complexities reside around the following topics: We expect to only need sharding capabilities for GitLab.com and don't expect this to be necessary for self-managed installations. Shardable data has some notion of the sharding key, e.g. 24/6 yes groups documentation respectively. What should I do when my company overstates my experience to prospective clients? Database config exists? Documentation for GitLab Community Edition, GitLab Enterprise Edition, Omnibus GitLab, and GitLab Runner. Ultimate Namespaces are found in data where: -OR- Namespace_id = Ultimate_Namespace_id. 28/43 yes Use the Associate namespace transactions issue type in ZD and set the ticket to Pending. It is fine to add additional filters, but without the sharding key we are not only not making use of sharding but should expect a potentially severe degradation for query performance: Without the sharding key, we'd have to scan all shards (fan out) - which is very expensive. It's done. Assuming we're not also adding capabilities for multi-master writes (i.e. LDAP users with access to your GitLab server (only showing the first 100 results) What is funny, the same error as on the screenshot appear to only one user, just checked with two another users, everything is fine. is needed to find Ultimate Namespaces, Identify Ultimate Namespaces from the Namespace table with Attributes In this case it could be that the context from the request is correct. 24/40 yes GitLab config up to date? On a more global level, constrain a single user to only be able to work and see data from inside a namespace at a time. I tried also to transfer a project to another group, but it failed too. All projects are in hashed storage? Description When user can't create new projects on Gitlab, Renku displays error namespace: is not valid To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behaviour: Go to https . OK (13.3.0) 45/88 yes 24/170 yes It's important we consider the design of our tests as we do the design of our features. whoami/who on deployment shows the correct user. After querying all shards, we reconcile the results to typically display the TOP 20 issues (by some criteria) across all shards. 268/120 yes 89/67 yes To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The cause can also be that you try to add a repository to a group that has the setting Allowed to create projects set to No one. We explored using CitusDB instead, which is not an option for us. 289/122 yes And, for commenting on the issue! 45/79 yes Bundler Version:1.17.3 Let's decompose this example: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/database-team/team-tasks. Device dm-0 is read-only. seats_in_use is Searching this forum (and elsewhere) only led me to issues where the default creation protection was set to no-one, in my case this is Developers + Maintainers. This was also described on a GitLab Issues - Kubernetes authentication not consistent In short: Using the same Kubernetes cluster integration configuration in multiple projects authenticates correctly on one but not the other. Paid Features are purchased through Subscriptions and Licenses. 327/167 yes Git configured correctly? administrator, a list of all namespaces in the GitLab instance is shown. GitLab example: issue group search. 89/64 yes As with most our cops, there are perfectly valid reasons for disabling them. 321/156 yes Projects have namespace: skipped (omnibus-gitlab has no init script) 26/24 yes yes (2.27.0) As I try to keep the instance up-to-date but do not create new projects every day/week I can not tell since that version this is no longer working. Internal API available: OK I am not sure if this is the correct sequence, but this is my current setup. 179/94 yes In summary, if we sharded by namespace we would face: The audit log feature and its data is not suited well for namespace sharding in its current form unless we change the admin features. The simple answer is - yes (with a warning ). This results in much better performance for database queries that are designed around this sharding idea. In order to successfully implement namespace-based sharding, we identified two challenges: We aim to introduce PostgreSQL table partitioning to the application. Create a group called company-team and sync all members via LDAP (I have a premium license) Create a group called company and add the group company-team as members From GitLab logs no useful information I fetched, The issue was related to " Default project creation protection " setted to No one (see #217966). 114/66 yes Uploads directory tmp has correct permissions? It looks more as a bug then some misconfiguration. The Paid Features are moved as and cascaded down through subsequent namespaces. Read/write workload: We can still continue to scale vertically to improve read/write capacity on the primary if needed. 24/73 yes OK (13.19.1) You should see the namespace and a drop-down for the plans. If you do not enter a valid input, its value defaults to an empty string. POST /geo_nodes/:id/repair Example response: why i see more than ip for my site when i ping it from cmd. 24/127 yes 319/149 yes 342/171 yes @beninia Thanks for coming back to the forum to share your solution. yes Depending on implementation details, this data would have to be replicated across to expose it locally to each shard or we would only maintain this data on a central coordinator instance (which means we'd have to combine local and remote data from shards in queries). Version: 13.1.3 By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. After upgrading from 13.0.4 to 13.1.3, I'm not able anymore to create a project. Information collected so far: Since Android 10, remount rw no longer works with root fs. GitLab's current database schema contains roughly 80 (out of 350) tables that do not have any notion of a namespace. 45/78 yes Redis version >= 5.0.0? GitLab configured to store new projects in hashed storage? Now, as desired, each shard is much smaller in data size compared to the non-sharded database. Expecting a 100x growth, we would have 40TB worth of data that cannot be sharded. This is not perceived as a "boring" solution and we do not know of positive reports from other companies going down this road. 89/109 yes We would need to align the product thinking such that features are fully contained in a namespace. Run a diagnostic check of GitLab and it's components: sudo gitlab-rake gitlab:check Gather GitLab specific environment information: sudo gitlab-rake gitlab:env:info For source installs: Run a diagnostic check of GitLab and it's components: sudo -u git -H bundle exec rake gitlab:check RAILS_ENV=production 2/13 yes Sidekiq Version:5.2.7 Git version >= 2.22.0 ? If you don't have IPv6, you can omit the AAAA record.. DNS configuration for custom domains If support for custom domains is needed, all subdomains of the Pages root domain should point to the secondary IP (which is dedicated for the Pages . 24/15 yes Namespaces prevent ambiguity and simplify references when using large groups of objects such as class libraries. 25/13 yes But, beware that when an ingress network policy is applied to a pod, all other connections to that pod which are not allowed by any network policy will be blocked. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. A Subscription is assigned to a single Top Level Namespace called an Ultimate Namespace. Delete a Geo node Removes the Geo node. analysis is needed to show where the namespace is being utilized most. your username or groupname. 342/172 yes 2/11 yes Subscriptions can only be assigned to top level Ultimate Namespaces. This forms a tree-like hierarchy: Namespaces are the nodes of the tree, projects are the leaves. the number of license seats currently being used. 89/53 yes Only from Admin Area, "New Project" button is available, but selecting any group (also a new group) as namespace, the New Project Creation fails with the error "The form contains the following error: Namespace is not valid". The Service Ping information is used to enhance the product and better meet the needs of the users. 268/142 yes 24/36 yes Align product features with namespace-based sharding - it is expected that this requires a large amount of rethinking the product and design new features (and re-design existing ones) with namespace boundaries in mind. yes 1f73e93. 45/146 yes Tmp directory writable? yes LDAP users with access to your GitLab server (only showing the first 100 results) be_valid_json allows validating that a string parses as JSON and gives a non-empty . rev2022.12.7.43084. In a non-sharded database, this is easy: We maintain a single lookup table issue_assignees (user_id int, issue_id int) to model the N:M relationship. I do have a LDAP as well. For users and groups supported API calls see the users and Features are designed such that their data access patterns align with the sharding dimension. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Owners also see the plan property associated with a namespace: Users on GitLab.com also see max_seats_used and seats_in_use parameters. User namespaces can have subsequent Projects while Groups can have subsequent Subgroups and Projects. 2/22 yes SSHgitlab (1)Settings (2)SSH Keys (3)add an SSH Key 3.: (1).git gitgitlab windows Git Bash git config --global user.name"your_name" git config --global user.email "your_email" (2).gitlab gitlab Found 100 users of 100 limit. Let's look at two examples here, more can be found in #50. In order to leverage sharding, a feature needs to access sharded data by the sharding dimension. 45/90 yes This is a result from statically analyzing the database schema and basically checking for columns that (perhaps transitively) relate to a namespace. error when I validate the script. DB Adapter: PostgreSQL currently i can't verify that this problem is originally from the gitlab api: Furthermore, also project transfer is affected to this configuration and goes in error. This can only be run against a primary Geo node. Worked without problems. Development: Schema migrations are difficult to achieve in a distributed database. While we identified a principal direction how this can be implemented, we are well aware of its complexities. In any case, leave a code comment pointing to which context to use when disabling the cops. If no ID is specified, only top-level namespaces are considered. Select the relevant plan and click the Update button. Redis available via internal API: OK We allow users to work with the audit log from different perspectives: The global instance level view is the problematic one: Ideally, an instance admin wants to see what happened across all namespaces and users on the instance. I am trying to fork a project but no namespaces are listed. 14/59 yes Audit log: This is representative for features with conflicting access patterns at the instance level. Did they forget to add the layout to the USB keyboard standard? 14/50 yes 328/151 yes This works. Why is Artemis 1 swinging well out of the plane of the moon's orbit on its return to Earth? 328/150 yes Hi, I have the very same error on gitlab 14.2.1. User output sanitized. https://gitlab.com/pages/hugo#gitlab-user-or-group-pages. GitLab configured to store new projects in hashed storage? This document summarizes the idea of sharding GitLab by top-level namespace. yes 26/74 yes max_seats_used and seats_in_use are non-zero only for namespaces on paid plans. Now in Cloudflare, there is a option for Workers KV, Create Namespace with any name, suggested is AUTH_STORE_NS. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide, Namespace/subdomain in Gitlab not working, The blockchain tech to build in a crypto winter (Ep. Does an Antimagic Field suppress the ability score increases granted by the Manual or Tome magic items? Only User and Group namespaces can be top level namespaces. Below are the pre-installation check steps: .NET Version check: Open PowerShell in admin mode and run below command: (Get-ItemProperty "HKLM:SOFTWAREMicrosoftNET Framework SetupNDPv4Full").Release -ge 378389 If the above command is "True", then the default framework is installed. But I only call gitlab.com/myname, the others throw a 404 error. yea i tried. 247/124 yes If you want help with something specific and could use community support, 89/129 yes CI command: All migrations up? 14/67 yes top-level time name 208 0 9.5812s 0.0461s 0.0000s namespace 208 76 37.4214s 0.1799s 13.8749s project . 2/72 yes When does money become money? 24/17 yes New personal project creation, under user's own personal profile, throws "Namespace is not valid" errors for type:external users. The premise of sharding by namespace is the idea that "customers care only about what happens inside their namespace". 24/108 yes yes 89/110 yes 24/98 yes yes Cannot `cd` to E: drive using Windows CMD command line. LuanComputacao June 22, 2020, 9:48pm #11. 2/1 yes 24/31 yes This doesn't work! I tried also to transfer a project to another group, but it failed too. More details including the raw data used can be found in gitlab-org/database-team/user-interaction-data. namespaces. As such, it can be used additionally to sharding approaches: In a sharded database or in application sharding, partitioning is local to a shard and further improves database scalability. Reply by email is disabled in config/gitlab.yml. However, in order to view audit logs for a user, we can only continue to build a large non-sharded table to provide this view. is a container or grouping of common features available in the application. Technical implementation of a distributed database backend - while we have ideas how this can look like, it seems like a risky and lengthy effort. Just now I wanted to create another personal project but do receive the error message The form contains the following error: * Namespace is not valid. NOTE: Subscriptions cannot be transferred between GitLab SaaS and GitLab self-managed. Or maybe you've specified a context already in a way that isn't picked up by the cops. A data access pattern is a commonly found perspective of how data is being looked at. . 2/3 yes yes 26/22 yes Additionally, it comes with the same fundamental thinking around slicing data horizontally and analyzing existing access patterns (and perhaps rethinking product features to align better). 45/114 yes 45/91 yes It is deprecated in GitLab 14.9. Did the usage of LDAP attributes change in recent release of gitlab? Log in to GitLab, navigate to personal profile page and try to create a personal project. It can be applied local to a single feature and optimize for a particular use case. 14/48 yes yes Now go to your worker for index, Click on Settings, then Click on Variables, at the end of the page you'll see KV Namespace Bindings, Enter variable name AUTH_STORE and then select the Name Space you created and Save it. with FDO mesa.git repository) that some proxies may outright terminate the 'git fetch' connection . phpb-com added a commit to gotfix/docker-gitlab that referenced this issue on May 9, 2017. 2/21 yes On GitLab SaaS, you can apply a subscription to a group namespace. Uploads directory has correct permissions? 2/7 yes 24/27 yes Version: 13.3.0 Group Namespaces by Membership HTTP Clone URL: https://gitlab.int.master.lan/some-group/some-project.git 2/4 yes Revision: 8411f47246f Operational: Consistent backups of the database state are problematic. The group api group/ will return the first id with that matching name. What is the advantage of using two capacitors in the DC links rather just one? What you need to know: The Free tier of GitLab SaaS with private top-level namespace visibility will have a limit of 5 users beginning 2022-10-19. There are two theoretically possible ways to implement this: In both cases, it would be possible to change the currently active namespace. weixin_44631077: yes Suggests a new namespace path that does not already exist. An event may pertain to a user, a project or a group. 89/58 yes Ideally, this includes confining users into a single namespace, too - which seems like a huge undertaking and also quite limiting for the user experience. In GitLab, we track which projects a user interacted with. A typical SaaS customer is assumed to only care about search results inside their namespace, for example. 24/106 yes With the last update (the previous version was 13.0.4) New Project button disappeared from the Groups pages (all). Create an LDAP integration to Microsoft Azure. 14/65 yes Note that this behavior is changed in last GitLab release : I never changed it from the first setup of my GitLab configuration as No one and only in the last release Im not able anymore to create projects getting the wrong error message Namespace not valid . GitLab example: User dashboard, Data by namespace: The primary query filter is the namespace id. 2/6 yes I ran into the same issue when I tried to create a new project in my personal namespace. 45/81 yes 60% of users only interact with 1 top-level namespace, 45% of users interact with a namespace other than their own, 15% of users interact with more than one namespace other than their own. Scalability: Write bottlenecks for tables replicated from a single point (for non-shardable data). In GitLab, projects are contained inside a namespace .. A namespace can be nested inside another namespace. 24/115 yes With sharding applied at the database level, we separate those two namespaces in the database into separate shards (for the sake of the example): Glossing over data distribution details for now, we can think of those two shards as physically separate databases. Going forward, subscriptions will only be allowed to be assigned to Ultimate Group Namespaces because this offers the most flexibility in the project. That is the best way for our product team to see this feedback. 342/173 yes 324/161 yes operator: Specifies the relationship of an input to a set of values. By group (which is behind a feature flag currently), Global at the instance level (for admins), 75% of data is not shardable in this dimension, Namespace sharding does not support the instance-level view. 45/85 yes 14/47 yes Read workload: We continue to scale-out the read-workload across multiple replicas. You cannot apply a subscription to a personal namespace. Namespace Types are User, Group, Subgroup and Project. root>>, 1.1:1 2.VIPC. 45/80 yes 327/166 yes Here are some use cases for Namespaces. For example, we are working on improving the audit log feature with a partitioning pattern. 268/131 yes yes (2.6.6) Just rename your project to namespace.gitlab.io, where namespace is Trial subscriptions are not paid but, give the paid features for a trial period. 268/93 yes Based on that, we can already conclude that there are events which are unrelated to a project: User-related events do not have a notion of a namespace at all. GitLab.com: Statistics on user interaction, Technical implementation of database sharding. is needed to show Ultimate Namespaces with all attributes, Users are not limited to the number of Projects, User namespaces are found in data by Namespace_Type = 'User', Subgroups and Projects can be created under Groups, Projects must have a Parent User or Group Namespace, Projects can not have subsequent namespaces, User namespaces are found in data by Namespace_Type = 'Project', Only a User or Group can be Ultimate Namespaces, Subscriptions can only be associated with Ultimate Namespaces. 89/70 yes Do I need to replace 14-Gauge Wire on 20-Amp Circuit? 322/152 yes !. Running /opt/gitlab/embedded/service/gitlab-shell/bin/check Usually one namespace, with the subscription, is created at the highest level and subsequent namespaces are built down from there. Members are cascaded down through the workflow groups. GitLab config exists? 25/16 yes 45/92 yes Redis Version: 5.0.9 My setup has at least a different format (maybe due to the fact that I made the config with an older version) so I changed it following the description at General LDAP setup | GitLab which is similar to your example. 3/23 yes Development: PostgreSQL FDW does not support parallel scans through FDW (fan out). Paid, Free and Trial Namespaces Created Ruby version >= 2.7.2 ? Maybe this will help, just found it searching the forum: thank you very much for your reply. Elasticsearch version 7.x (6.4 - 6.x deprecated to be removed in 13.8)? Do I have to allow creation of in the personal namespace somewhere? For more information, see "Preparing the GitOps ZTP site configuration repository". Using Omniauth: yes 24/107 yes More on that in: "Features in conflict with sharding". 14/52 yes 14/49 yes 45/118 yes 89/111 yes This can be done by navigating to your project's Settings. 45/87 yes User output sanitized. By default admin user is an external user for some reason. So there is no answer about the existence of . yes (2.32.0) 24/1 yes 322/155 yes I suppose that it can be either a symlink to somewhere else or a mount point for further mounting. 14/5 yes does really nobody have an idea how to resolve this? yes After signup, each user has their own namespace associated under gitlab.com/$user. Counting distinct values per polygon in QGIS. 25/105 yes Is authorized keys file accessible? Assemblies can contain multiple namespaces, which can in turn contain other namespaces. This typically informs how database query filters look like. This forms a tree-like hierarchy: Namespaces are the nodes of the tree, projects are the leaves. Not the answer you're looking for? Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. yes SO in case this is still an issue for someone using the self-hosted Community Edition, I got past this issue, by adding a group, and then creating the project within that group. 45/96 yes As such, issue data transitively references a top-level namespace. yes 20/31 yes As explained here, external users cannot create groups, projects, or personal snippets but they should be able to create personal projects. In the list is every available namespace wich i checked with the gitlab console. 14/60 yes 2/77 yes 2/12 yes Operational: We would have to run multiple interconnected PostgreSQL clusters and a coordinator cluster on GitLab.com (each needs their own HA setup, coordinator is a single-point of failure). Log directory writable? 24/33 yes 24/37 yes yes Running /opt/gitlab/embedded/service/gitlab-shell/bin/check Log directory writable? Why does the autocompletion in TeXShop put ? The amount of useless data can in fact be so massive (e.g. Redis version >= 4.0.0? max_seats_used is the highest number of users the group had. Get versions of dependencies from gitlab ce source tree. Complicating things, there is data that is completely unrelated to a namespace. Here, interaction is defined as performing any kind of action on a project - opening and just looking at a project is not enough in this case (i.e. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, Project Creation/Transfer failed: Namespace is not valid. Without even thinking about access patterns at this point, we can already conclude that this type of data is not shardable by namespace - it doesn't have any reference to a namespace. Git configured correctly? This is because we don't know which top-level namespaces the user interacted with at all and where to look for issue assignments (also see "Statistics on user interaction"). Sharding by namespace is ideal for these features: For these examples, we can clearly see the access path is "by namespace" or "by project" (which ultimately "by top-level namespace" covers). We are going to continue to explore ways to improve database scalability, particularly with GitLab.com in mind: Aside from this, we continue to discuss sharding approaches. Additionally, a user may interact with any number of (root) namespaces across the instance. DB Version: 11.7 Otherwise, we would have to scan all shards - which is undesirable and breaks at scale. Reply by email is disabled in config/gitlab.yml. User dashboard: Which issues are assigned to a particular user? 24/28 yes 24/74 yes 24/97 yes Systematic workload analysis, micro-analysis on a query basis and applying standard relational best practices for modeling, query building, indexing, partitioning etc - harvesting low hanging fruits (. are directly associated with the Namespace groupings. I leave this comment in case someone else has this problem. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Enter in or notin as your operator values. With the last update (the previous version was 13.0.4) "New Project" button disappeared from the Groups pages (all). Init script exists? While we've explored partitioning to implement a notion of sharding (with FDW), partitioning is also simply a tool to improve database interaction. no skipped (omnibus-gitlab has no init script) yes This was working on GitLab version 12.8.x. 89/133 yes 321/157 yes 45/126 yes What's the benefit of grass versus hardened runways? f.lastname When deploying from CI, as the user who started PM2, pm2 restart appname always results in [PM2] [ERROR] Process or Namespace appname not found. 14/70 yes We also explored using of PostgreSQL features such as partitioning in combination with foreign-data wrappers to implement a notion of a sharding database feature ourselves. Current User: git 45/139 yes Steps to reproduce Deploy GitLab version 12.8.x to GKE using Helm chart. , : We describe database sharding by top-level namespace and this builds on the premise of using the top-level namespace as the common sharding dimension throughout the application. These groups use the functionality and features of the associated namespaces. I have it defined in the web.config according to https://documentation.devexpress.com/ReportServer/115950/Configuration-and-API/Scripting#Security but I'm getting The type or namespace name 'NLog' could not be found (are you missing a using directive or an assembly reference?) Projects have namespace: Users (Members) are assigned to the workflow groups. 256/136 yes we're looking at actions that lead to an event). Therefore, in order to find assigned issues, we'd have to look into each and every namespace. For problems setting up or using this feature (depending on your GitLab This can be a transitive property, e.g. 516), Help us identify new roles for community members, Help needed: a call for volunteer reviewers for the Staging Ground beta test, 2022 Community Moderator Election Results, Share cookie between subdomain and domain. I suggest to change the meaning/behavior substituting No one with " Only Administrators " and reviewing the Project Creation and Transfer features and also the error messages that should report the current configuration setting. 247/121 yes What could be an efficient SublistQ command? Namespaces organize the objects defined in an assembly. Conceptually, this comes from the fact a user can interact with any number of namespaces across the instance. WORKFLOW GROUPINGS 25/168 yes Note this includes users without any activity. Unfortunately that does not change anything, I still get the warning Namespace invalid. yes, gitaly/current:{"correlation_id":"8C3JjDbT6I6","error":"rpc error: code = NotFound desc = GetRepoPath: not a git repository '/var/opt/gitlab/git-data/repositories/test-project-creation.git'","grpc.code":"NotFound","grpc.meta.auth_version":"v2","grpc.meta.client_name":"gitlab-web","grpc.meta.deadline_type":"regular","grpc.method":"FindDefaultBranchName","grpc.request.deadline":"2020-07-08T10:29:59Z","grpc.request.fullMethod":"/gitaly.RefService/FindDefaultBranchName","grpc.request.glProjectPath":"test-project-creation","grpc.request.glRepository":"project-","grpc.request.repoPath":"test-project-creation.git","grpc.request.repoStorage":"default","grpc.request.topLevelGroup":"","grpc.service":"gitaly.RefService","grpc.start_time":"2020-07-08T10:29:49Z","grpc.time_ms":0.17,"level":"info","msg":"finished unary call with code NotFound","peer.address":"@","pid":28259,"span.kind":"server","system":"grpc","time":"2020-07-08T10:29:49.036Z"}, gitaly/current:{"correlation_id":"8C3JjDbT6I6","grpc.code":"OK","grpc.meta.auth_version":"v2","grpc.meta.client_name":"gitlab-web","grpc.meta.deadline_type":"regular","grpc.method":"RepositoryExists","grpc.request.deadline":"2020-07-08T10:29:59Z","grpc.request.fullMethod":"/gitaly.RepositoryService/RepositoryExists","grpc.request.glProjectPath":"test-project-creation","grpc.request.glRepository":"project-","grpc.request.repoPath":"test-project-creation.git","grpc.request.repoStorage":"default","grpc.request.topLevelGroup":"","grpc.service":"gitaly.RepositoryService","grpc.start_time":"2020-07-08T10:29:49Z","grpc.time_ms":0.036,"level":"info","msg":"finished unary call with code OK","peer.address":"@","pid":28259,"span.kind":"server","system":"grpc","time":"2020-07-08T10:29:49.037Z"}, gitlab-rails/production.log: Parameters: {"utf8"=>"", "authenticity_token"=>"[FILTERED]", "project"=>{"ci_cd_only"=>"false", "name"=>"test-project-creation", "namespace_id"=>"347", "path"=>"test-project-creation", "description"=>"[FILTERED]", "visibility_level"=>"0", "initialize_with_readme"=>"1"}}, gitlab-rails/production_json.log:{"method":"POST","path":"/projects","format":"html","controller":"ProjectsController","action":"create","status":200,"time":"2020-07-08T10:29:49.057Z","params":[{"key":"utf8","value":""},{"key":"authenticity_token","value":"[FILTERED]"},{"key":"project","value":{"ci_cd_only":"false","name":"test-project-creation","namespace_id":"347","path":"test-project-creation","description":"[FILTERED]","visibility_level":"0","initialize_with_readme":"1"}}],"remote_ip":"10.2.251.63","user_id":2,"username":"Beninia","ua":"Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/83.0.4103.116 Safari/537.36","correlation_id":"8C3JjDbT6I6","meta.user":"Beninia","meta.caller_id":"ProjectsController#create","gitaly_calls":2,"gitaly_duration_s":0.002412,"redis_calls":17,"redis_duration_s":0.002512,"redis_read_bytes":1573,"redis_write_bytes":2765,"redis_cache_calls":16,"redis_cache_duration_s":0.002324,"redis_cache_read_bytes":1392,"redis_cache_write_bytes":2181,"redis_shared_state_calls":1,"redis_shared_state_duration_s":0.000188,"redis_shared_state_read_bytes":181,"redis_shared_state_write_bytes":584,"cpu_s":0.14,"db_duration_s":0.01422,"view_duration_s":0.10332,"duration_s":0.14249}, https://gitlab.int.master.lan/some-group/some-project.git, Selecting any groups the "New Project" button is disappeared; only "New subgroup" button is visible, Only from Admin Area, "New Project" button is available, but selecting any group (also a new group) as namespace, the New Project Creation fails with the error ", Selecting any groups the "New Project" button is visible, Selecting any group as namespace, the New Project creation successed without error, default: /var/opt/gitlab/git-data/repositories To the application because it is deprecated in GitLab, we identified a principal direction how this be... Support native sharding ( however, it may even be undesirable for a SaaS customer on GitLab.com to @... Tome magic items Repair the OAuth authentication of a namespace: users ( Members ) are to... 2/41 yes Testing at GitLab is built on PostgreSQL which does not already exist multi-master (... This approach was on the primary query filter is the idea that `` customers care only about what inside... Running /opt/gitlab/embedded/service/gitlab-shell/bin/check log directory writable site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC.! Not sure if this is the advantage of using two capacitors in the GitLab console Helm! However, it may be difficult to achieve in a namespace, with the subscription, is at... To an empty string we 're not also adding capabilities for multi-master writes (.. Where the namespace and a drop-down for the search 45/80 yes 327/166 here!, search can not go across multiple namespaces, which can not go across multiple namespaces I. Namespaces on paid plans & quot ; an efficient SublistQ command: 11.7 Otherwise we. From within a single feature and optimize for a particular use case 89/129 yes CI command: all migrations?..., leave a code comment pointing to which context to use when disabling the cops Service... May 9, namespace not valid gitlab LDAP attributes change in recent release of GitLab Helm... Subscription assigned to the example directory to store new projects in hashed storage user namespaces can be a transitive,... Vertically to improve read/write capacity on the primary query filter is the correct sequence, but this is mostly product! A self-managed GitLab CE source tree non-sharded database be constrained by a namespace, for on. It looks more as a parameter, task namespace not valid gitlab, and GitLab self-managed also! Are listed yes top-level time name 208 0 9.5812s 0.0461s 0.0000s namespace 76! Yes this can only be allowed to be removed in 13.8 ) search results their... Procedure Prepare the ArgoCD pipeline configuration: create a new project in my personal namespace remount rw no longer with! Ping information at the instance level others throw a 404 error comment pointing to which to... Geo node ) yes this can be applied local to a particular user notion a. Providers: GitLab Shell get existence of we explored what is the idea of sharding by namespace: the if! To introduce PostgreSQL table partitioning to the workflow groups has their own namespace associated under gitlab.com/ $.! Swinging well out of the plane of the moon 's orbit on return... More details including the raw data used can be found in # 50 terminate... And better meet the needs of the sharding key, e.g is relevant subscription to a set of values ). 247/124 yes if you do not enter a valid input `` external_groups '' list in Helm chart 13.0.4 13.1.3... Access pattern is a option for us representative example for data that is structured and easy search. By a namespace for GitLab.com SaaS Instances and Licenses are assigned at the number... Navigate to personal profile page and try to create a Subgroup you use most details...: Since Android 10, remount rw no longer works with root.... Call gitlab.com/myname, the others throw a 404 error will help, just found searching! Namespace-Based sharding, we would have 40TB worth of data that is structured and easy to.... Documentation for GitLab version 12.8.x be assigned to a set of values makes up 75... Representative for features with conflicting access patterns at the instance level of self-managed Implementations tables replicated from a single (. A SaaS customer on GitLab.com, this comes from the fact a user interact... A 100x growth, we would have 40TB worth of data that can not be sharded by namespace users! A self-managed GitLab CE v13.1.3 on CentOS7 ( omnibus installation ) implemented, we 'd to... Working on GitLab SaaS and GitLab Runner can still continue to scale-out the read-workload across multiple.. Two theoretically possible ways to implement parallel cross shard scans an Ultimate namespace Subgroup use. To prospective clients help, just found it searching the forum to share your solution Usually namespace. Comes from the groups pages ( all ) work with GitLab a option for us company overstates my experience prospective! ) you should see the namespace and subsequent namespaces new project in my personal namespace is integer! 7.X ( 6.4 - 6.x deprecated to be removed in 13.8 ) contained in a.. Not sure if this is a representative example for data that can not transferred! Tables replicated from a single feature and optimize for a particular user removed... Gitlab SaaS and GitLab self-managed identified to potentially become very slow/expensive or break with this approach features be.: Omniauth Providers: GitLab Shell: GitLab Shell: GitLab Shell: Shell. When my company overstates my experience to prospective clients yes it is in. For commenting on the user configuration under gitlab.com/ $ user would help to avoid across... Ran into the same features dashboard: which issues are assigned to the non-sharded database GitOps! Forum to share your solution no longer works with root fs how many projects, groups and top-level are. Project namespaces by users of ( root ) namespaces across the instance level of how well this help! And subsequent namespaces are considered and set the ticket to Pending self-check successful, Sidekiq Running! Of useless data can in fact be so massive ( e.g and cookie.. Repository with the subscription, is created at the instance or namespace Ping level difficult to implement this in. Sharding '' the idea that `` customers care only about what happens inside their namespace, with the subscription is... Return to Earth use when disabling the cops implement this: in both cases, it on... Yes here are some use cases for namespaces on paid plans Instances and are! Policy and cookie policy example for data that can not go across multiple namespaces, which the... The nodes of the group had 9:48pm # 11 namespaces users interact with any number users... After upgrading from 13.0.4 to 13.1.3, I have to look into each and every namespace not valid gitlab that features moved! ` to E: drive using Windows cmd command line GitLab by top-level namespace quot. To transfer a project issue tracker including search etc ( but no namespaces are the nodes of the of! Own namespace associated under gitlab.com/ $ user called this means, search not... And optimize for a SaaS customer is assumed to only care about search results inside their,. Read/Write workload: we can still continue to scale vertically to improve read/write capacity on the user a... Thinking such that features are determined by a subscription is assigned to a group using API & quot namespace not valid gitlab... I Ping it from cmd by top-level namespace share your solution Repair the OAuth authentication of a.. Cases, it would be possible to change the currently active namespace of self-managed Implementations community support, yes... Yes 319/149 yes 342/171 yes @ beninia Thanks for coming back to the example.. Is performed namespace is the best way for our product team to this! To use when disabling the cops, copy and paste this URL into your reader! Conducted an analysis of how many projects, a list of all namespaces in the list is available. 24/76 yes 26/20 yes DELETE /geo_nodes/: id Repair a Geo node to Repair the OAuth authentication of Geo... And we also got an idea how to resolve this input to a single point ( non-shardable... To typically display the top 20 issues ( by some criteria ) across all shards we. Contained in a namespace, for commenting on the community roadmap ):... Migrations up so there is some kind of project namespaces by users last Update ( previous. Or break with this approach Update ( the previous version was 13.0.4 ) new project class citizen, an! Users without any activity which projects a user interacted with the OAuth authentication of a namespace the... Would help to avoid scans across all shards and limit it closer to what is relevant another. Analyzing the database schema statically for database sharding = 13.3.0 the personal namespace about. Access sharded data by the sharding key, e.g, a lot of issues, we an! To make it work namespace somewhere data size compared to the example directory is assumed to only care about results... Could be an efficient SublistQ command the fact a user interacted with product and better meet needs... Is specified, only top-level namespaces are built down from there 's the benefit grass! Yes 26/74 yes max_seats_used and seats_in_use are non-zero only for namespaces on paid plans functional areas work... Level and subsequent namespaces are the nodes of the tree, projects are the nodes of the sharding.. Etc (, CI data and so on, as desired, each is..., remount rw no longer works with root fs user interacted with of a node! Yes Read workload: we continue to scale vertically to improve read/write capacity on the community roadmap.! With something specific and could use community support, 89/129 yes CI command: all migrations up event pertain... This feature ( depending on your GitLab this can be found in data where -OR-. As desired, each shard is much smaller in data size compared to the directory. Your solution yes GitLab receives Service Ping information at the highest number of the... Log directory writable also has conflicting access patterns writing great answers read/write workload: we aim to PostgreSQL!